Here’s a simple question-answering tool you can use to tell stories with
unexpected twists, or as drop-in replacement for the oracle in your favorite
GM emulator. (I like so1um and the
Its two defining features are:
- Quick interpretation
- No arithmetic, large table lookups, or state tracking to understand the
results of a roll. Instead, we only do value comparisons between dice and a
high/low judgment. After a test roll or two, this can be done with a glance.
- Lots of tools like this one inject randomness in the form of plot twists,
but the twist is usually introduced in the course of answering the question,
or after it’s been answered. If you’re GMing or playing solo, that means
you’re adding elements to your narration that you didn’t expect, but it’s not
really surprising, the way that players get surprised when they think they
know what’s going on and it turns out they don’t. This tool tries to mimic
that feeling of surprise by making the GM into an unreliable narrator;
whenever you ask a question using this mechanic, it’s possible that the
question itself is wrong, which fosters less predictable twists.
Consulting the oracle
You’ll need 2d6 in one color, and 2d6 in another. I’ll use black and white.
To resolve a yes-or-no question, roll one black die and one white die.
If white is highest, the answer is Yes. If black is highest, the answer is No.
To find out if the answer is more nuanced than just a plain Yes or No,
also look at the value on each die. If both are low (3 or less), add But.
If both are high (4 or more), add And.
You ask, “Does the vampire catch fire?” You roll one white die and one black
die and get 5 4.
That’s a Yes, because the white die is higher, and an And, because
both rolls are 4 or higher.
If the black die had come up as 3,
it would have been a plain Yes instead.
Likely and unlikely events
Yes and No are equally likely if you use one die of each color.
If circumstances are different, include an additional die in favor of the more
likely outcome when you roll, but only keep the higher die of that color when
You ask, “Does Lydia make it over the fence?” Unlike the werewolf that’s after
her, she’s just a puny human, so it’s pretty unlikely she’ll succeed. You roll
one white die and two black dice. You get
3 3 5.
You ignore the black 3, so the answer is a plain No; she doesn’t make it over.
If you do the math, you might notice that you’re about three times more
likely to get And than But on an uneven roll, since you’re throwing out low
dice. This means more extreme outcomes for extra drama.
What if I roll doubles?
If the dice are equal, some
behind the question is wrong! This means that you’re taking something for
granted that makes it impossible to answer with “Yes” or “No.” If it’s obvious
how you’re the question could be assuming something, change it and ask something
else. You can also use your favorite plot twist generator if you need to,
but keep in mind that the question itself was wrong; you’ll need to revise
your assumptions about the situation and the world, not just add something new.
If you’ve never thought about questions this way, it can be tricky to recognize
what one presupposes. One approach is to imagine what would have to be the same
about the scenario if the answer were either Yes or No. For example, if I
ask, “Does the villain’s sidekick escape before the train explodes?” there are
a lot of things that would have to be the same under either answer, the most
obvious one being that the train explodes! (This is a presupposition introduced
by the use of before.) There are other presuppositions in there too, like that
the villain has a sidekick, and even that there’s a train.
You ask, “Does Sam grab the gun from the mobster?” and roll
This means it’s not possible to answer “Yes” or “No,” but why? You think,
“Well, maybe the thing that the mobster is holding only looks like a gun,”
but decide that can’t work because it was fired just a minute ago.
Instead, you realize the mobster isn’t a mobster at all, but an undercover cop!
You follow up with a crucial question: “Does Sam know he’s interrupting a
sting operation?” Fingers crossed…
||Updated to v1.0, fixing typos, tweaking examples, and adding PDF version on itch.io
||Ricardo from Tragos Games has translated Recluse v0.2 into Portuguese! Check it out.
||Added more discussion of presupposition (v0.2).
||Posted initial version (v0.1).
“Recluse” by Graven Utterance is licensed under CC BY 4.0.
Here’s a thought experiment in narrative control. The GM of my biweekly
Starfinder campaign asks of my previous post:
I’m not familiar with DRYH and how the dice pools work but this looks really cool.
Something similar to a Raise the Stakes concept.
I’ve always liked allowing players to accomplish more if their willing to take some risks.
Do you think it would be possible or practical to use DBYP in a Starfinder game?
I’m a big fan of the supplement linked in that quote, which provides additional
mechanical hooks for players in d20 games to control the narrative. In games
with lighter rulesets, you can usually get the same kind of creative
contributions from players just by encouraging them to ad lib, but in
D&D/3/3.5/Pathfinder/Starfinder, I’ve always had more luck by (paradoxically)
introducing extra rules of this sort.
So what would it look like to mash up Don’t Rest Your Head and Starfinder (or
another d20-derived game), and what would you gain from it?
DRYH rules in a nutshell
For the uninitiated, Don’t Rest Your Head is a game where you play an
insomniac whose sleeplessness has let them see through the world’s illusions.
They have a weird power as a result (a Madness talent) and are hunted by
nightmares given physical form. A partial rules summary:
- You have three pools of six-sided dice: Resolve (3 dice), Exhaustion (1 to 6
dice), and Madness (up to 6 dice), which you roll together against the GM’s
Pain dice pool when you want to do something risky. Every die that comes up 1,
2, or 3 counts as a success. The side with more successes wins…
- …but that win is accompanied by consequences depending on which pool
dominates the roll. The dominating pool is the one with the highest single
value. (Drop tied dice until you have a winner, then go in the order that the
pools were introduced above if there’s nothing left.)
- It’s only a good thing when Resolve dominates; otherwise, your Exhaustion will
start spiralling out of control, your Madness will trigger a fight-or-flight
response and/or consume you, or the situation will become increasingly painful
for your character and the people they care about.
- You always roll Resolve and your current Exhaustion, but you can choose how
much Madness to use; those dice sit in front of you, every turn, waiting for
you to decide whether the action warrants the risk that using them poses.
I’m going in a different thematic direction with DBYP,
but as an emergent property of the sytem, both are games of hard choices with a
strong resource-management component that’s a little like Yahtzee: You can
accomplish almost anything, but how much are you willing to push your luck to
Torches vs lighter fluid
This kind of resource-management stands in contrast to games in the tradition of
the original fantasy game (including its rules-heavy children like Starfinder),
where you tend to be counting down to oblivion: Consumable items like torches,
spells, and especially hit points all represent scarce resources that the player
must deploy judiciously to prevent their character from dying.
In DRYH, you’re not in danger of running out of light in a dark place. You’re
in danger of burning the place to the ground while you’re still inside.
So let’s turn up the heat in Starfinder.
Drift, Health, and Void dice
To model an ability that a character can use to an unlimited degree but at great
personal risk, assign it a pool of six-sided Drift dice. (I’m using that name
because the Drift is a big unknown in Starfinder, and so is a reasonable source
for weird powers, but feel free to look elsewhere for inspiration.) Assign at
least three tiers of effects to the pool, e.g.:
Drift-ability: Cross-dimensional resonance
Your exposure to the raw energies of the Drift let you peer for a moment
beyond the edge of time and space, into other times and spaces. As a
standard action, channel the Drift for any of the following effects.
||Cast Mirror image on target touched creature. It lasts 1 minute.
||Flood target touched creature with memories of another life. Will save DC 20 to act normally.
||Replace target touched creature with their double from a mirror universe. Details up to the GM.
I think the most critical aspect of this subsystem is to tie the consequences
back to the original system, which in this case means hit point depletion.
Starfinder characters have two-tiers of health (Stamina and Hit Points), so
we’ll define the Health dice that the player rolls alongside their Drift dice
to correspond to different levels of health. I’ve chosen not to include a pool
like Exhaustion because it models a longer-term resource and would mean tracking
extra bits for this subsystem.
The size of the GM’s opposing Void dice pool is left to GM fiat, but I
wouldn’t recommend going over 4, and you should tell the players what you’re
going to oppose with while they’re making their decision to roll. Keep in mind
that they’ll only have a 50/50 shot to succeed if your Void pool is the same
size as their Health+Drift pool. Here’s the final proposal:
Channel the Drift
When you channel the Drift, assemble your pools of six-sided dice and roll
against the GM’s Void dice:
- Start with one Health die. Add a second if you have all your HP. Add a
third if you have all your stamina.
- Pick up as many Drift dice as you need to get the desired effect.
- Roll all your dice and count up every die that comes up 1, 2, or 3.
- The GM will also roll some number of Void dice (usually 2-4), and count
successes the same way.
If you have the same or more successess, the effect takes place, otherwise
- Figure out which of the three pools dominates the roll.
- If Health dominates, nothing more happens. (Whew!)
- If Drift dominates, act randomly for a number of rounds equal to the size
of your Drift pool, probably not in your own best interest.
- If Void dominates, you lose health: If you have stamina, drop it all. If
you don’t, drop to 1 HP. If you have no stamina and you’re at 1 HP, drop
Drift domination is a pretty punishing rule, but since the player decides when
it’s worth it to push it and the possible outcomes are known prior to the roll,
I don’t think it’s unfair. The player also has Resolve points that they can use
to recover – characters are pretty resilient in Starfinder.
Don’t Break Your Pact (DBYP) is my
house-ruled hack of Don’t Rest Your Head for stories of mystic heroism.
From a mechanical perspective the bones of the hack are pretty simple;
Discipline, Exhaustion, and Madness dice pools from DRYH become:
- Represents the core of who you are. You have 3 dice in this pool, and if you
lose them, you’re likely to lose yourself and what’s important to you.
- Represents what makes you exceptional. You start with 2 and can push yourself
to gain more (max 6). Having a lot of guts dice means you’re near your limit
and you’re in danger of having the situation get out of control, whether that
means losing your nerve or going into a frenzy.
- Represent fantastic power granted by a patron. You can have access to up
to 6 pact dice total, possibly from multiple patrons.
There are some differences in how these pools work, but it’s basically still the
case that you have a “safe” pool (Soul), a “push it” pool (Guts), and a
magical pool that you can exploit at great personal risk (Pact). Games of this
sort allow the characters to accomplish a lot as long as their players are
willing to take risks, and so the drama often comes from the danger of
collateral damage to things the characters value.
I’ve been trying to hone in on what kinds of stories DBYP is supposed to help
tell and build an meta-setting
that supports it. In terms of inspirations, I think the list below is as short
as I can get without leaving out anything essential.
- Dragon Ball (Akira Toriyama)
- Le Monde d’Edena (Mœbius)
- Avatar: The Last Airbender & The Legend of Korra
- Tengen Toppa Gurren Lagann
- Chrono Trigger
- The Earthsea Cycle (Ursula K. Le Guin)
- The Old Kingdom series (Garth Nix)
- The Broken Earth trilogy (N. K. Jemisin)
Bonus: There’s also a visual inspiration album